The Kentucky Supreme Court ruled unanimously Thursday that a printer cannot be forced to print T-shirts that violate his faith.
In a case that dragged on for seven years, Blaine Adamson, owner of Hands On Originals, a promotional printer in Lexington, declined to print T-shirts for the Lexington Pride Festival, hosted by the Gay and Lesbian Services Organization.
“Today’s decision makes clear that this case never should have happened,” said Alliance Defending Freedom senior counsel Jim Campbell, who argued the case, in a statement. “For more than seven years, government officials used this case to turn Blaine’s life upside down, even though we told them from the beginning that the lawsuit didn’t comply with the city’s own legal requirements. The First Amendment protects Blaine’s right to continue serving all people while declining to print messages that violate his faith.”
The state’s high court wrote in its opinion, “this matter must be dismissed because the Gay and Lesbian Services Organization, the original party to bring this action before the Lexington-Fayette Urban County Human Rights Commission, lacked statutory standing to assert a claim against Hands On Originals under the Lexington-Fayette Urban County Government ordinance.”
A concurring opinion from Justice David Buckingham cited recent U.S. Supreme Court precedent prohibiting compelled speech, writing, “Hands On was in good faith objecting to the message it was being asked to disseminate. … Forcing free and independent individuals to endorse ideas they find objectionable is always demeaning.”
In 2012, Adamson referred the group to another printer that would do it for the same price, but the group brought a complaint to the Lexington-Fayette County Human Rights Commission.
“I have gay customers and employ gay people,” Adamson said in a video op-ed for The Daily Signal in 2017. “For example, we have printed materials for a local band called Mother Jane whose lead singer is a lesbian. That was never a problem for us because, as I said, we’ll work with everyone, but we can’t print all messages.”
Sorry. No data so far.
Adamson also talked about other T-shirts he wouldn’t print, including one that would have read “Homosexuality is a sin.”
“I didn’t feel right making that one either. I don’t think that’s how Jesus would have handled the issue; Jesus would have balanced grace and truth,” Adamson said.
In 2014, the Lexington-Fayette commission ruled Adamson must print the messages. All state-level courts ruled in Adamson’s favor.
As the case wound through the courts, Adamson received support from lesbians who own a print shop in New Jersey and agreed with his right not to print messages he finds objectionable. He received 13 “friend of the court” briefs from across the country, including from Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin, a Republican, and officials from 10 states.
- Why The Legacy Media is Afraid of Free Speech on Social Media
- Americans Paid for the Internet, We Deserve Free Speech On It
- Texas takes the lead in fight against social media censorship: Bill would allow state to sue tech giants over free speech violations
- CBS News, NYT Reporter Suggest U.S. Scrap Free Speech In Favor Of New Zealand-Style Censorship
- Trump’s Executive Order to Colleges: Protect Free Speech or Risk Billions in Federal Grants
Courtesy of The Daily Signal
Fred Lucas is the White House correspondent for The Daily Signal and co-host of “The Right Side of History” podcast. Lucas is also the author of “Tainted by Suspicion: The Secret Deals and Electoral Chaos of Disputed Presidential Elections.” Send an email to Fred.
Your Daily Briefing:
Fight Online Censorship!
Get the news Google and Facebook don't want you to see: Sign up for DC Dirty Laundry's daily briefing and do your own thinking!